WOWebsites

Why I Turned Down a High-Value Client in My Niche Target Market

Why I Turned Down a High-Value Client in My Niche Target Market

As an SEO professional since 2008, I’ve had to make difficult decisions, but turning down a potential client in an industry I specialize in was one of the toughest. Have you ever had to say no to a client because you simply couldn’t deliver what they were asking for?

Earlier this year, I was approached by the Marketing Manager of a Caribbean-based jewelry store, a brand with three locations in luxury Ritz-Carlton hotels across the Caribbean. She was also the owner’s daughter, so I knew I was already speaking to top management/top decision-maker. This is exactly the type of client I specialize in—luxury tourism businesses in the Caribbean. So initially, turning them down wasn’t even on the table. However, after a thorough review of their needs and their website, I realized I had no choice.

The client wanted me to manage a Pay-Per-Click (PPC) campaign on their existing website. But here’s the problem: their website wasn’t set up for a successful PPC campaign. There were three major obstacles:

  1. Non-Targeted Pages: The site’s pages weren’t optimized for any relevant keywords. For a PPC campaign to succeed, the landing pages need to target specific search terms to reduce cost-per-click and maximize ROI. Their pages didn’t, meaning the client would end up spending more money with little return. I suggested we update the landing pages for better keyword targeting, but the client declined. They only wanted to run the PPC campaign as-is.
  2. Lack of Conversion Design: Even if we had managed to get visitors through the ads, the website wasn’t designed to convert those clicks into sales. The pages were more like brochures than actionable sales funnels. I recommended a redesign of the landing pages to improve conversions, but again, the client was set on launching the PPC campaign without any changes.
  3. Slow Website Speed: One of the biggest issues was the website’s slow loading time. In today’s digital landscape, speed is crucial—especially for a PPC campaign. A slow website leads to higher bounce rates, meaning visitors are more likely to leave before the page even loads. This not only wastes the client’s ad spend but also hurts their quality score, increasing the cost-per-click. When I raised this issue, the client didn’t want to address it.
Best in Search

Get in touch with us, today

Call, chat with a representative, or fill out the form

Despite these challenges, the client insisted on moving forward with their existing setup. I had to make a tough call—I turned down the project. My reputation and expertise were on the line, and running a campaign doomed to fail wasn’t something I could stand behind.

Interestingly, about a month later, the same client reached out again. The Marketing Manager, who had initially been firm in her decision, asked if I would reconsider taking on the project. I appreciated her continued interest and took the opportunity to explain once more why addressing the technical issues was crucial for the campaign’s success. Despite our lengthy discussions, the client still wasn’t comfortable making the necessary changes, so I ultimately had to decline again, knowing that moving forward without those adjustments wouldn’t serve their best interests. It was one of the hardest decisions I’ve ever had to make.

The good news is that she mentioned she would consider my recommendations for next year’s budget and appreciated the time and effort I had spent educating her about online marketing.

Saying no to a project you know you’re an expert in can be incredibly hard, but sometimes it’s the right decision to maintain the quality and integrity of your work. In this case, it was the only option.

Picture of <span style="font-size:20px;">by</span> Fevi Yu
by Fevi Yu

SEO Consultant since 2008

Fevi Yu is a seasoned SEO consultant, digital agency founder, and the visionary behind the Basic Website Package—an innovative web and SEO solution crafted for business owners aiming for immediate results. She’s also the creator of the Unlimited WP Maintenance Package, which provides comprehensive WordPress support to enhance website performance and ensure long-term success. This article was written with the assistance of generative AI for enhanced clarity and precision.

Inquire for More Information